John Henkel writes for domainAlot.com
Written By John Henkel - 13 Jun 2025
AI Appraisal Tools provided by Domain Registrars over Inflate the Value of Domains

For years, the traditional mindset around owning a domain name has centred on holding it until a buyer comes along with the right offer. It's a passive approach that is guaranteed to lead to long periods of inactivity, with domain owners paying renewal fees year after year, forced to invest continually in their digital assets, and all in the hope that one day someone sees the value they always believed was there. But there's a more active, financially rewarding alternative that's steadily gaining traction, and it's known as Domain Leasing. So, let's take a closer look.

Try Before You Buy

Leasing a domain essentially flips the script. Instead of waiting, you turn your digital asset into a revenue-generating tool. Think of it like owning a piece of real estate. You could let it sit vacant, hoping for a big sale, or you could rent it out and earn steady income while the property potentially appreciates in value. Domains work in precisely the same way.

Leasing allows a third party to use your domain for a fixed monthly or annual fee. At domainAlot.com, we prefer potential lessee's to offer domain owners a fixed annual fee. That way, the domain owner (lessor) gains a lump sum, and the lessee saves on monthly transaction fees and charges. In other words, everybody wins.

With a lease agreement, the lessee can build their brand, launch a product, or test a new market, often on a Premium Domain name that may have otherwise been out of reach if buying outright. Meanwhile, you keep ownership of your domain. This kind of arrangement again benefits both parties. For the lessee, it's less capital-intensive than a full purchase. For the owner, it's an opportunity to create cash flow and add value to the domain at the same time.

Once Committed, There's Commitment

But wait, there's another value here that often gets overlooked, and it's one that is arguably the single most important for any domain owner.

The vast majority of owners considering to lease their domains, do so, quite simply because they have been unable to sell them. There can be any number of reasons for why a domain remains unsold.

  • Cost (it may be over-priced).
  • Interest (the market sees no value in it).
  • Visibility (listed on the wrong or less optimal market place).
  • Awareness (it simply drowns amidst the flood of domains that already exist on marketplaces all shouting for attention).

Whatever the reason, the predicament remains the same — there's no takers. So, the domain owner decides to generate some passive revenue while waiting for that all allusive sale. Meanwhile, the lessee has been building traction and confidence using the domain and as the leasing contract nears its end is left with a decision to make.

  1. Do I abandon all that I have built?
  2. Or should I buy the domain outright?

For the domain owner, where this has always been the goal, essentially what they received was an advanced down payment on their digital asset and with it, the commitment of an actual buyer.

The Value Of Domain Leasing Is Greater Than Revenue

Here's where it gets interesting. When someone builds a real business or service on your domain, they're not just parking a site. They're actively promoting the name, driving traffic, and generating backlinks, all of which increase the domain's visibility and long-term SEO authority. That, in turn, makes your domain more valuable—both in terms of brand recognition and resale potential.

Take the case of BullionVault.com, which began as a leased domain. Before becoming the world's largest online service for gold and silver trading, BullionVault was a domain leased by its founder from an investor who recognised its potential. The deal allowed the founder to launch quickly without the high upfront cost of purchasing the name. As the site grew and gained traction, its domain authority and value soared. Eventually, the company bought the domain outright, by which point it had already become a globally recognised brand. What started as a lease turned into a multi-million-dollar asset.

And there's more. Another example is Toys.com. The domain was leased for a time before Toys "R" Us believing that it was shorter, and easier for users to type than the recognised toysrus which loses memorability without the "R". Ultimately Toys "R" Us purchased Toys.com for $5.1 million. Why? Because the domain was already gaining organic traffic and had brand affinity, which contributed to its high valuation. Something they themselves had created. Leasing it first gave the company an opportunity to test and benefit from the domain's power before committing to the full acquisition.

A Flexible Model That Is Gaining In Popularity

For domain owners, leasing offers more control and options. It allows you to structure leases as short-term agreements and retain flexibility or offer longer terms with buyout clauses. This way, if a startup using your domain turns into a major brand, you still have plenty to gain.

What's more, domains that are active — meaning they host legitimate content and services — tend to rank better in search engines than domains that have stood idly parked for months, or even years. When your domain is live and in use, it avoids being flagged as dormant or low quality. That kind of digital activity not only boosts traffic but signals relevance to search engines, making it more appealing to future buyers. This is something that every domain owner should try to remember. Yes, ideally, the current lessee would be interested in buying your domain, but if they're not, then the successful use of your property is the next best thing. Their activity will only increase your domain's value and allow you in turn to increase both your sales asking price, and / or leasing price for the next lessee.

Psychology Has A Say

In addition to value creation, there's the psychological factor. A domain in use feels more "real" to potential buyers. It shows the name works in practice, not just in theory. In fact, the domain marketplace "Flippa" is built entirely around this principle, i.e. are you selling a domain or a business? A working web site is a business and should theoretically be worth more than just a domain name, right? And if it is, that means more commission for them, so the incentive is fairly obvious. Bottom line, when there's measurable data—monthly visitors, backlinks, brand mentions, and so forth, it's easier to justify a higher asking price.

In a market where Premium Domain sales can be unpredictable and sporadic, leasing offers stability and upside. It creates a win-win scenario. Someone gets a head start on building their business with a strong domain, and you, the owner, start earning money right away while your digital asset gains exposure and value.

A Smarter Path To Passive Income

If you are holding onto a domain, waiting for the perfect buyer to show up, consider taking a more proactive approach. Leasing isn't just a fallback plan, it's often the smarter move. With annual renewal fees increasing each year, a domain is no longer an asset you can afford to just simply invest in maintaining. It's an asset you must realise.

So, what's your next step, and where to begin?

Our Guide To Leasing A Domain is a great place to start. It explains the principles of leasing in greater detail, what you can expect, the options available to you, and your rights as a lessor. Then, take a look at the domains you own. Are any of them just sitting there, costing you money and gathering digital dust? If so, maybe now's the time to do something about it? Maybe now's the time to list them for lease?

If you'd rather try yourself, then why not reach out to startups, entrepreneurs, or businesses that might benefit from the name? The point is to get your domains working for you, not you working for your domains.

Your don't need to wait for someone to buy your domain. It can start earning revenue for you now, and in an age where so many influencers talk about "side-hustles," there's never been an easier way for you to generate passive income than by leveraging your very own digital assets.